Wednesday, December 14, 2011

The Most Damaging Employee Of All

Being an HR professional and also formerly a leader in the operations environment of a large manufacturing facility, I have certainly seen my share of employee performance issues - the slacker, whiner, bully, suck up, etc. etc.  I like to think I've pretty much seen it all but I'm hesitant to say that as I am periodically very surprised by a new issue.  Some issues are easier to deal with than others.  For probably 90% of employee issues, a frank conversation and clear expectations will change performance.  But, oh boy, that other 10% can be quite a challenge.

Of course there is no one size fits all approach.  People are people.  And for those of you that tend to like things black or white, you are not going to be happy about this - people are very gray.  Every person comes with their own set of unique perceptions, ideas, reactions, and results.  The good news is there are some simple guidelines for the most part.

Routine Performance Issues
For example, the slacker just requires a little micro-management and clear goals so you can manage the performance (either towards improvement or out of the position).  This micro-managing is not intended to be a permanent fix, it's a short term solution toward improvement.  The "Whiner" likely wants attention and this is the only way they know how to get it.  Once you dig past the surface performance and get to the root cause of the problem it is much easier to solve.  I've been known to sit a problem employee down and say "Here are the expectations.  What do you need from us in order to perform to expectations?"  Putting the ball in their court seems to lead to resolution much faster than trying to guess what we need to do.

The Most Damaging Employee
There is one type of employee however, that I firmly believe is the most damaging to any business.  They are a cancer cell in the business world and if I stick to that analogy, only quick detection and massive amounts of chemotherapy can cure the damage they cause.  And they are the most difficult to detect because they are masters of deception.  I would much rather deal with a slacker, people in conflict, lack of teamwork, or a difficult supervisor than deal with this person.  By now, your interest should be sufficiently peaked.  Who am I referring to?  The Gossip.
I'm not talking about the morning break room chit chat regarding who is having an affair or who is spending too much time on Facebook.  It's not unusual for all employees to spend a certain amount of time gossiping and it's impossible to think you are going to eliminate that - actually, a certain amount of gossip may be good.  I'm talking about the person that derails careers, destroys morale, and purposefully takes information they have and twists it to hurt others and cause drama.  These are the back stabbers that will throw you under the bus the first chance the get but act like your best friend the rest of the time.  Why are they the worst you might ask?  Because they are often difficult to detect, they disrupt morale, and when you confront them, they will act like they have no idea what you are talking about.  Just in case you didn't realize this, when your team is focused on drama, they aren't focused on work.

You may wonder how to handle this employee because if your organization is very big at all, I guarantee you have one or two.  The first step is to detect and derail them.  If this person is brave enough to bring the gossip to you, consider yourself lucky.  You don't want to stop anyone from bringing information to you but you want to make sure they know you are going to dig to get all the facts before jumping on their drama bandwagon.  So, let me handle this a couple of ways.

Scenario:  Your Gossip brings juicy info to you.
1.  Thank them for bringing you the info (after all it's better they brought it to you than to everyone else).
2.  Ask lots of questions (and I do mean lots).
     How did you come to find this out?
     Did you personally see them do this?
     Did they tell you that or did you infer that?
     What exactly did they say?
     What exactly did you see?
     How do you know?
     Who have you shared this with?
     Did you see the email?

Once you start asking questions and they can't answer one, they will begin to realize they can't make things up.  This approach alone will stifle a bit of the gossip.
3.  Caution them that things aren't always what they seem and educate them on the damaging effects of gossip.
4.  If necessary, ensure them you will handle the situation but you will not be reporting back to them unless it has to do with them personally.  Tell them you expect them to keep what they know private as you seek more information.
5.  If you hear they have shared the information with others after your talk, address the gossip as a performance issue just as you would absenteeism.  It disrupts the work environment and should be handled as such.

Scenario:  Your Gossip is Sharing Information With Others.
1.  Invite them into a private area for a chat.
2.  Let them know you are aware of something they have shared (do not divulge your source if at all possible as it will only generate conflict).  Explain what it is you heard, and allow them to respond.
3.  Thank them for being honest with you.  If they deny saying anything ask your question a couple of different ways.  If they continue to deny it skip to the final step in this process.
4.  Ask lots of questions (see above for examples)
5.   Caution them that things aren't always what they seem and educate them on the damaging effects of gossip.
6.  If necessary, ensure them you will handle the situation but you will not be reporting back to them unless it has to do with them personally.  Tell them you expect them to keep what they know private as you seek more information.
7.  Explain that in the future you would like them to come to you with this information and not generate gossip within the department.  Explain that gossip will destroy a team and you need their help and making sure that doesn't happen.
8.  Explain that gossiping is a performance issue as it disrupts the work environment and will be handled as such.

On a more positive note, the "Gossip" can be a great resource for you when implementing change.  Think about it, you have someone on your team that likes to talk . . . .make sure they are armed with the information you want others to have.  They can be your greatest resource if you know how to utilize them.  This post is getting way too long so I'll cover than topic in a future post.

What are your thoughts regarding the impact of the Gossip?  What success have you had in dealing with this person?  I want to hear your thoughts!

Mari

No comments:

Post a Comment

Would love to hear your thoughts on this topic!